The Costs of Inflation

Why inflation is costly

  • Shoeleather costs — effort to hold less cash when inflation is high.
  • Menu costs — the cost of changing posted prices.
  • Relative-price distortions — staggered price changes misallocate resources.
  • Redistribution (unexpected inflation) — fixed nominal contracts transfer wealth between borrowers and lenders.
  • Hyperinflation — all costs balloon; money stops working as a store of value.

Who wins from a surprise?

A loan sets its nominal rate on expected inflation: \(i = r + \pi^e\). The lender’s realized real return is \(i - \pi\).

  • If actual \(\pi >\) expected → the borrower gains (repays in cheaper dollars).
  • If actual \(\pi <\) expected → the lender gains.

Try it. Fix the expected inflation the loan was priced on, then move actual inflation and watch who gains.

What to notice

  • Set actual = expected → ex post equals ex ante → no redistribution.
  • Push actual above expected → the lender’s realized return falls → borrower wins.
  • Menu, shoeleather, and relative-price costs happen even when inflation is fully expected; redistribution is the extra cost of the surprise.